Where to Find Cape Cod Pies and Desserts for Thanksgiving

Michael Leighton
Michael Leighton
Published on November 11, 2019

The turkey may be the centerpiece of Thanksgiving Day dinner for most families, but the dessert is the grand finale in every home! Give yourself a break and stop by one of these amazing bakeries and let them do some of the work for you and impress your guests with your delicious Cape Cod pies and desserts. Here is our list of Where to Find Cape Cod Pies and Desserts for Thanksgiving:

Brewster Pies and Desserts

Eat Cake 4 Breakfast

Location: 302 Underpass Road, Brewster

Website

Phone: (508) 896-4444

Hours: Wednesday – Saturday 7:00 am – 1:00 pm; Sunday 8:00 am – 12:00 pm

Details: Eat Cake 4 Breakfast is a local favorite with all you need for your Thanksgiving Day celebration. All Thanksgiving pie orders must be made by the Sunday before Thanksgiving, before 12:00 in the afternoon. If you are planning on ordering croissants or other pastries, the orders must be for a dozen or more. If you are looking for fewer than a dozen, it is first come first serve. When ordering your Thanksgiving pie, payment is due in full. There is a variety of pies available to order for $25 each such as pumpkin, pecan and lemon meringue among many others. Apple and pecan chocolate tarts are also available for $50 each.

Centerville Pies and Desserts

Centerville Pie Company

Location: 1671 Falmouth Road, Centerville

Website

Phone: (774) 470-1406

Hours: Monday – Saturday 8:00 am – 6:00 pm; Sunday 8:00 am – 1:00 pm

Details: Shortly after opening their doors in 2009, the “Pie Ladies” (Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley) were discovered by Oprah Winfrey and their pies were even named one of her favorite things that year! Although their restaurant closed last year, you can still pick up one of their famous pies at their bakery, at local retail stores (listed on their website) or you can even order your Thanksgiving pies online directly on their website.

Chatham Pies and Desserts

Marion’s Pie Shop

Location: 2022 Main Street, Chatham

Website

Phone: (508) 432-9439

Hours: Monday – Saturday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm and Sunday 8:00 am – 4:00 pm

Details: Come in to Marion’s Pie Shop to order your Thanksgiving pies or give them a call (but please do not email your orders). There are 6 inch and 9 inch fresh fruit pies (such as strawberry peach, blueberry crumb and cherry) that are made daily to buy along with pumpkin, and savory pies that include beef steak, chicken and clam. Make sure you call ahead to ensure that your favorite pie is available for purchase. Marion’s Pie Shop has been featured on the Phantom Gourmet, the Chronicle Show and TV Diner.

Chatham Village Café and Bakery

Location: 69 Crowell Road, Chatham

Website

Phone: (508) 945-2525 or (508) 945-3229

Hours: Monday – Saturday 7:00 am – 3:00 pm and Sunday 7:00 am – 1:00 pm

Details: Chatham Village Café and Bakery has pies of all sizes in addition to cakes, pastries and cupcakes for your Thanksgiving celebration. Choose from 5 inch, 7 inch and 9 inch pies in a variety of flavors such as apple, apple caramel crumb, pumpkin, mincemeat and many more. Download the order form where you can choose your cupcake design and order your rolls or breads to complete your meal. All orders must be in by Monday November 19th and all orders have to be picked up from the bakery on Wednesday November 21st at 2:00pm.

Interested in Buying Real Estate on Cape Cod?

$
$
Dennis Pies and Desserts

Kender & Sisters Kitchen and Coffee

Location: 593 Main Street (Route 6A), Dennis

Website

Phone: (508) 258-5001

Hours: Tuesday – Saturday 7:30 am – 3:00 pm; Sunday 7:30 am – 2:00 pm; Monday 7:30 am – 1:00 pm

Details: Kender & Sisters Kitchen and Coffee has an assortment of Thanksgiving Day essentials such as nine inch pies, quick breads, Nantucket spice cake, chocolate cake (with chocolate ganache) buttermilk biscuits and cookies. You can also find a variety of sides and appetizers to complete your meal and let you enjoy more time with the family. Thanksgiving goodie orders can be placed in person in the shop or over the phone. There are three pick up dates: Monday November 25th, Tuesday November 26th and Wednesday November 27th so get your orders in quick!

Underground Bakery

Location: 780 Main Street (Route 6A), Dennis

Website

Phone: (508) 385-4700

Hours: Monday – Saturday 6:00 am – 5:00 pm and Sunday 6:00 am – 12:00 pm

Details: Whether you are looking for a homemade macaroni and cheese side, festive cupcakes, squash bread or pear walnut upside down cake, the Underground Bakery has your Thanksgiving Day meal essentials. Their holiday menu has a little something for everyone, offering a pumpkin swirl cheesecake and flourless chocolate torte in addition to their assortment of pie options.

Orleans Pies and Desserts

Cottage Street Bakery

Location: 5 Cottage Street, Orleans

Website

Phone: (508) 255-2821

Hours: Sunday – Thursday 7:00 am – 3:00 pm; Friday and Saturday 7:00 am – 5:00 pm

Details: Cottage Street Bakery only makes mince pie for Thanksgiving, so you do not want to miss your chance to order this pie and include it in your Thanksgiving Day celebration. In addition to mince pie, they have apple cranberry, sour cream apple, chocolate cream and patriots pie along with a long list of others too large to list here so check out their website. Pies are made fresh daily to choose from in the case, but if you have one particular flavor in mind you should call a couple of days in advance so they can make it fresh for you and ensure it is there waiting.

Cape Cod Pies and Desserts for Thanksgiving

Enjoy your family and friends this Thanksgiving Day and stop by one of these amazing bakeries so they can make dessert for you. Are you looking for something fun to do the night before Thanksgiving? Check out our blog, “Cape Cod Nightlife” for some fun out on the town. If you are preparing to do some Black Friday shopping the morning after Thanksgiving, check out our blog, “Cape Cod Coffee Shops Open in the Off Season” so you are fueled up to catch those sales!

close
Get A FREE Home Valuation!
LET'S DO IT!
X